Dog Chew Toys: What Makes a Good One, and What Makes a Bad One
Hard isn't the same as durable. How to pick a chew toy that survives your dog without cracking a tooth.
Dogs need to chew. It relieves boredom, burns energy and keeps them off your shoes. But the chew toy aisle is full of products that are either gone in ten minutes or so hard they can break teeth.
A good chew toy sits between those two: tough enough to last, soft enough to give a little under a tooth, and too big to swallow.
Good vs. bad at a glance
What makes a good one
- It gives a little
You can press a dent into it with your thumbnail. Teeth are strong, but they crack against things that don't flex.
- It's the right size
It's too big to fit entirely in your dog's mouth or slip down the throat. When in doubt, size up.
- Two openings, not one
Hollow toys and balls should be open at both ends, so a tongue can't get stuck by suction.
- One solid piece
There's nothing glued, stitched or clipped on that a determined dog can pull off and swallow.
- Rated for your dog's chewing
Good brands sort toys by chew strength: gentle, average, power chewer. Buy for the dog you have, not the one on the box.
- Easy to clean
Dishwasher-safe rubber or TPE is ideal, especially if you stuff it with food.
What makes a bad one
- Too hard to dent
Antlers, cooked bones, hooves, hard nylon and hard plastic are common causes of fractured teeth, especially the big upper chewing teeth.
- Breaks into chunks or shards
Pieces that come off can be swallowed and cause choking or a blockage.
- Ball or tube with a single hole
Suction can trap a dog's tongue inside. This sends dogs to the vet more often than you'd think.
- Too small for the dog
A ball that fits behind the back teeth is a choking hazard, even if the dog has played with it safely for months.
- "Indestructible" on the label
No toy is. The claim tends to sell harder material, not a safer toy.
- No materials listed, strong chemical smell
If the seller won't say what it's made of, assume the worst.
Checks you can do before you buy
- Thumbnail test Press your thumbnail into it. If it won't dent at all, it's too hard for teeth.
- Kneecap test Tap it gently on your kneecap. If that would hurt, it's too hard.
- Size check Hold it next to your dog's open mouth. It should be clearly too big to swallow.
- Hole check Any hollow part needs an opening at each end.
- Twist test Twist and pull every part. Anything that moves now will come off later.
Picks that pass the checklist
These meet the "good" list above. Even so, every pet is different, so start supervised.
KONG Classic
Best for Most dogs, and stuffing with food
Natural rubber that bounces and gives under teeth. It's open at both ends, comes in sizes from extra small to XXL, and can be stuffed and frozen for a long chew. Power chewers can step up to the black KONG Extreme.
Watch out: Pick the size for your dog's weight, and size up if you're between two.
See it on Amazon Paid linkWest Paw Zogoflex toys (Tux, Hurley)
Best for Average to strong chewers who like to carry their toy around
A flexible, dishwasher-safe material that floats and is recyclable. Tux has a pocket for treats, and West Paw offers a guarantee against damage from dogs (check the current terms).
Watch out: Flexible doesn't mean indestructible. Take it away once chunks are missing.
See it on Amazon Paid linkGoughnuts rings and sticks
Best for Power chewers who destroy everything else
Thick rubber with a red layer inside. When you see red, the toy is worn and it's time to replace it, so you don't have to guess.
Watch out: It's very firm. Run the thumbnail test with your own dog's teeth in mind.
See it on Amazon Paid linkAs an Amazon Associate, Petsuasion earns from qualifying purchases.
Questions people ask
Are antlers and bones safe for dogs?
Many vets advise against them. They're harder than tooth enamel, and broken teeth from hard chews are common. Cooked bones can also splinter.
How often should I replace a chew toy?
When pieces are missing, it has cracked, or it has worn down small enough to swallow. Check it every week.
Should I leave my dog alone with a chew toy?
Only with one you've watched them use safely for a while. New toys should be used with you around.
This is general information, not veterinary advice. If your pet swallows something, or you're worried, call your vet.
Keep reading
Plush & squeaky dog toys
Dogs love a squeaker. Here's how to tell a well-built plush toy from one that ends up as stuffing on the rug.
Good vs. bad Cats · ToysCat wand & teaser toys
The best toy for most indoor cats, if you choose well and put it away after play.
Good vs. bad Cats · ToysCat puzzle & treat toys
Make your cat work for its food, without frustrating it or leaving a mess you can't clean.
Good vs. bad