Full Moon vs. Regular Kibble: What's Actually in the Bag
We put Full Moon's air-dried dog food next to a familiar grocery-store kibble and read both labels line by line: ingredients, protein, fat, additives and cost.


Most dog food bags look alike from the front: a happy dog, a pile of fresh-looking meat or vegetables, and the word "complete". The real differences are on the back, in two places most of us skip: the ingredient list and the guaranteed analysis.
So we read them. On one side is Full Moon Pure Protein, an air-dried food from a company best known for human-grade jerky treats. On the other is Pedigree Complete Nutrition, one of the most familiar bags in the grocery aisle and a fair example of what "regular" kibble looks like. Here's what the labels say, what that means for your dog, and why Full Moon comes out ahead for us, with the tradeoffs included.
The labels, side by side
| What we compared | Typical grocery kibble | Full Moon Pure Protein |
|---|---|---|
| First ingredient | Whole grain corn | Beef (Better here: Full Moon Pure Protein) |
| Main animal protein | Meat and bone meal (species not named) | Beef, pork, turkey, turkey liver (Better here: Full Moon Pure Protein) |
| Where the chicken is | Natural flavor (source of roasted chicken flavor) | No chicken in this recipe |
| Crude protein (min) | 21% | 31% (Better here: Full Moon Pure Protein) |
| Crude fat (min) | 10% | 29% |
| Crude fiber (max) | 4% | 2% |
| Moisture (max) | 12% | 16% |
| Calories | 324 kcal per cup | 451 kcal per cup |
| Artificial colors | Red 40, Yellow 5, Yellow 6, Blue 2 | None (Better here: Full Moon Pure Protein) |
| Preservatives | BHA, BHT, citric acid | Citric acid, green tea extract (Better here: Full Moon Pure Protein) |
| Grains, soy, peas | Corn, wheat, soybean meal, dried peas | None |
| How it's made | Extruded kibble | Air-dried, jerky-style bites |
| Complete and balanced for | Adult dogs | Adult dogs only |
| Cost per 1,000 calories* | About $0.43 | About $7.86 (Better here: Typical grocery kibble) |
Highlighted cells show which food does better on that line. *Chewy prices on November 21, 2026 (Pedigree 40-lb bag, Full Moon 32-oz bag). Prices change; the gap is what matters.
Protein and fat, with the water taken out
Dry matter basis, worked out from each label's guaranteed analysis (protein and fat are minimums, so actual values may be a little higher).
What's actually in the bag
Ingredients are listed by weight before cooking, so the first few make up most of the food. Fresh meat is mostly water, which pulls it up the list; that's why the protein numbers above matter too. The first 5 ingredients are highlighted.
Typical grocery kibble
- Whole Grain Corn
- Meat And Bone Meal
- Soybean Meal
- Animal Fat (Preserved With BHA And Citric Acid)
- Whole Grain Wheat
- Corn Protein Meal
- Natural Flavor (Source Of Roasted Chicken Flavor)
- Dried Plain Beet Pulp
- Salt
- Potassium Chloride
- Choline Chloride
- DL-Methionine
- Calcium Carbonate
- Dried Peas
- Minerals (Zinc Sulfate, Copper Sulfate, Sodium Selenite, Potassium Iodide)
- Vitamins (Vitamin E Supplement, Niacin Supplement, Vitamin B5 [Calcium Pantothenate], Vitamin C [L-Ascorbyl-2-Polyphosphate], Vitamin A Supplement, Vitamin B2 [Riboflavin], Vitamin B12 Supplement, Vitamin B1 [Thiamine Mononitrate], Vitamin D3 Supplement, Vitamin B6 [Pyridoxine Hydrochloride], Biotin, Vitamin B9 [Folic Acid])
- L-Tryptophan
- Dried Carrots
- BHT (Preservative)
- BHA (Preservative)
- Red 40
- Yellow 5
- Yellow 6
- Blue 2
- Citric Acid (Preservative)
Full Moon Pure Protein
- Beef
- Pork
- Turkey
- Turkey Liver
- Apple Pomace
- Sunflower Oil
- Dicalcium Phosphate
- Salt
- Citric Acid (a Preservative)
- Dipotassium Phosphate
- Calcium Carbonate
- Magnesium Gluconate
- Green Tea Extract
- Fish Oil Powder
- Zinc Proteinate
- Copper Proteinate
- Vitamin E Supplement
- Manganese Proteinate
- Vitamin D3 Supplement
- Potassium Iodide
- Thiamine Hydrochloride
Reading the kibble label
Pedigree's first ingredient is corn, followed by meat and bone meal and soybean meal. Corn isn't poison, and dogs can digest cooked grains. But when a plant leads the list, much of the protein and most of the calories come from plants rather than meat. That fits the numbers: 21% protein, and roughly half the calories from carbohydrate, by our estimate from the label.
"Meat and bone meal" is a rendered ingredient. Under the pet food industry's official definitions, "meat" means mammal tissue, and the label doesn't say which animal. So despite the roasted chicken on the front of the bag, the chicken on the ingredient list is a flavor.
Then there are the extras. Red 40, Yellow 5, Yellow 6 and Blue 2 are there for the person pouring the food. Your dog doesn't care what color kibble is. The fat is preserved with BHA, and the recipe also lists BHT. Both are approved for use in pet food, but the U.S. National Toxicology Program lists BHA as "reasonably anticipated to be a human carcinogen" based on animal studies. Many owners would rather avoid them when natural preservatives work.
Reading the Full Moon label
Full Moon's first four ingredients are beef, pork, turkey and turkey liver, and the company says meat and liver make up 90% of the recipe. The rest is mostly vitamins and minerals to make it complete, plus apple pomace, sunflower oil and fish oil. It's preserved with citric acid and green tea extract. There are no artificial colors, grains, soy, peas or glycerin.
On paper it delivers: 31% protein and 29% fat, versus 21% and 10% for the kibble. Full Moon says its ingredients are human grade and made to USDA standards for people food, with meat from Perdue farms. Instead of being extruded like kibble, the food is air-dried into soft, jerky-style bites.
It carries an AAFCO statement for adult maintenance, which means it's formulated as a complete diet for grown dogs. It can be a full meal, not just a topper.
The part most reviews skip: it's rich
With the water taken out, Full Moon is about 37% protein and 35% fat. By our estimate, roughly 6 in 10 of its calories come from fat. Measured per calorie, it has about 15% more protein than the kibble but more than twice the fat.
That's great for a lean, active dog or a picky eater. It's not what you want for a dog who is overweight or has had pancreatitis. Those dogs need a vet's input before any switch. It's also dense: a cup of Full Moon has about 40% more calories than a cup of kibble, so don't scoop it like kibble.
Why we recommend Full Moon, and what to weigh
Why it wins
- Meat you can name, first
Beef, pork, turkey and turkey liver lead the list, rather than corn and an unnamed meat meal.
- More protein from animals
31% protein on the label, versus 21%, and it comes from meat rather than corn and soy.
- Nothing just for show
No artificial colors, no BHA or BHT, no fillers. Preserved with citric acid and green tea extract.
- A complete diet, not just a treat
Formulated to meet AAFCO nutrient profiles for adult dogs, so it can be the whole meal.
- Picky eaters tend to go for it
Soft, jerky-style bites from a jerky-treat company. Many owners use it to win over fussy dogs and seniors with few teeth.
- No peas or legumes
The FDA has looked into a possible link between legume-heavy diets and heart disease (DCM) in some dogs. No cause has been proven, but Full Moon leaves peas out completely.
The tradeoffs
- It costs a lot more
About 18 times the kibble per calorie at today's prices. For a 50-lb dog, roughly $7 a day versus about 40 cents.
- High in fat
Not a fit for overweight dogs or dogs with a history of pancreatitis without your vet's OK.
- Adults only
Full Moon says Pure Protein is formulated for adult dogs, so it's not for puppies.
- "Beef" isn't only beef
The beef recipe also contains pork and turkey, so it won't work for dogs with a poultry allergy.
- Small bags
It comes in 1- and 2-pound bags, which is fine for small dogs but adds up fast for big ones.
- Kibble isn't the enemy
Pedigree meets AAFCO standards too, and plenty of dogs live long, healthy lives on it. Full Moon is better food, not the only safe food.
OUR TAKE
The verdict
For ingredients and nutrition, Full Moon is clearly the better food. You can see exactly what's in it, most of it is meat, and nothing is added only to make it look good. That's why we recommend it over a typical grocery kibble.
The smart way to use it depends on your dog and budget. For a small dog, it can be the whole meal. For a bigger dog, try it as a topper: replace about a quarter of the kibble with Full Moon, cut the kibble so the calories stay the same, and you get much of the benefit for a fraction of the price.
If you make the switch
- Switch slowly Mix it in over 7 to 10 days, starting with about a quarter of the meal, to avoid an upset stomach.
- Measure by calories, not cups Full Moon is about 451 kcal per cup, versus 324 for this kibble. Full Moon's own chart suggests 1¾ to 2 cups a day for a 41 to 50 lb dog.
- Watch the waistline Check your dog's weight after a few weeks and adjust. Rich food makes it easy to overfeed.
- Keep water out Air-dried food has less moisture than fresh food, so always keep fresh water nearby.
Meat first
Full Moon Pure Protein Air Dried Dog Food
The appeal Real meat you can name, first on the list.
- Beef, pork, turkey and turkey liver lead the ingredients
- 31% protein, no artificial colors, BHA or BHT
- Complete for adult dogs as a meal or a topper
Watch out: Rich and pricey. Adults only, measure carefully, and ask your vet first if your dog is overweight.
Find on Amazon Paid link. Pick the beef, chicken or turkey recipe and check the bag size on the listing.As an Amazon Associate, Petsuasion earns from qualifying purchases.
Questions people ask
Is Full Moon a treat or a dog food?
Both exist. Full Moon started with jerky treats, but Pure Protein Air Dried is a complete dog food for adult dogs, with an AAFCO statement for adult maintenance. It also makes a frozen line called Freshly Crafted.
Is Full Moon good for puppies?
Not Pure Protein. Full Moon says it's formulated for adult dogs only. Puppies need a food made for growth.
Why does Full Moon have so much fat?
It's mostly meat, and meat brings fat with it. That makes it tasty and energy-dense. It's fine for many healthy dogs, but ask your vet first if your dog is overweight or has had pancreatitis.
Is Pedigree bad for dogs?
No. It's complete and balanced, affordable, and many dogs do well on it. Our concern is what it's built from: corn first, an unnamed meat meal, artificial colors and BHA/BHT. If you can afford better, the label says Full Moon is better.
Can I mix Full Moon with my dog's current kibble?
Yes. Full Moon says it can be fed as a full meal or a topper. Cut the kibble back so the total calories stay about the same.
Sources
- Full Moon Pure Protein Air Dried Beef Recipe (ingredients, nutrition, feeding chart)
- Full Moon Pure Protein Beef on Chewy (price, label)
- Pedigree Complete Nutrition Roasted Chicken & Vegetable on Chewy (ingredients, guaranteed analysis, price)
- FDA: investigation into diet and canine dilated cardiomyopathy
- National Toxicology Program, Report on Carcinogens: butylated hydroxyanisole (BHA)
This is general information from published labels, not veterinary advice. Your vet knows your dog best, especially before a diet change for a dog with health conditions.
Watch the 30-second version on our Facebook page.
Keep reading
Dog chew toys
Hard isn't the same as durable. How to pick a chew toy that survives your dog without cracking a tooth.
Explore the guide Dogs · ToysPlush & squeaky dog toys
Dogs love a squeaker. Here's how to tell a well-built plush toy from one that ends up as stuffing on the rug.
Explore the guide